By the Beard of Mohammed! Inside Topkapı Palace

02-06-15 - Bosphoros View from SarayburnuNo trip to Istanbul is really complete without a visit to Topkapı Palace, the seat of the Ottoman sultans from shortly after the conquest until the mid-19th century, when the court moved to the laughably decadent Dolmabahçe. However, it isn’t really a site that I can take that seriously. Except for the views; those are amazing.

Now, I do fully admit to a bias toward the Roman and Byzantine. I’ve caught myself calling later Ottoman additions to Byzantine churches “adulterations” (I am decidedly an iconodule). I wish we still had the even the ruin of the Great Palace, and would trade Topkapı for it in a minute. It may just be the pulling-for-the-underdog side of my personality. After all, I don’t cheer for the Persians when reading about Thermopylae. I don’t cheer for the Greeks when reading the Iliad. I think Constantine XI showed far more heart and character than the sultan who conquered his city.

Of course, I don’t hate Topkapı Palace, but to me it will never have the soul of a Hagia Sophia. You go to the great church for a sense of awe and amazement. You go to Topkapı to giggle at Mohammed’s beard.

02-06-15 - 15th Century Ottoman ArmorNo, seriously – I’d have a picture if they allowed them. Topkapı is the site of many religious relics, of which maybe one or two are even plausible fakes. They have the staff of Moses, the sword of David, and my personal favorite, the saucepan of Abraham. (Four thousand years old! Have they ever seen artifacts that are four thousand years old? I have. They look like potsherds. Largely because they’re potsherds.) They also have some formerly-Byzantine relics, like the gold and jewel-encased arm bones and skull fragment of John the Baptist. It blows my mind to think that some poor peasant who had his grave robbed more than a thousand years ago has millions of people looking at his skull every year. But the silliest thing is probably the many, many strands of Mohammed’s beard. If you laid out all the fragments of the true cross, you’d have enough telephone poles for Memphis. If you wove all the strands of Mohammed’s beard, you could knit enough sweaters for Fargo.

02-06-15 - Topkapi Dagger ReproductionThat said, I do think Topkapı is worth the visit. Go to giggle at the silly relics, but after that, check out the harem to see how the sultans and their women actually lived. For roughly $6 is was worth the admission. Of course, you’ll also have to see the extensive collection of enormous jewels, including ~50 and ~80 carat diamonds. They have a famous dagger fitted with massive emeralds on its hilt which a friend of mine has asked to buy for him to use as a letter opener. Despite repeated inquiries, I’m mostly met with confusion, although they sell reproductions in the gift shop. And they have gold candlesticks that weigh more than 100 pounds each. 100 pounds of gold! Each! For candlesticks!

I also really enjoyed seeing the weapons collection that the sultans accumulated over the years. There is an array of swords belonging to Mehmed Fatih – none belonging to Constantine XI, sadly – and some late medieval arms and armor of interest. There are also plenty of ceremonial weapons like jewel-encrusted axes and jade maces. To me these impractical weapons are somewhat less interesting, but they would admittedly be quite a beautiful way to kill people. If you’re into that.

02-06-15 - Hungarian Two-Handed SwordsProbably the best part of the weapons exhibit, though, are the 12th century Hungarian two-handed swords. These are so massive that if they were plated in gold, the sultans would have stuck candles in them. They weren’t just taller than Michelle, they were taller than me. I snuck a picture, despite this being not allowed and fairly strictly enforced. I even saw security run over to picture-takers and watch as they were made to delete their photos. So I apologize a bit for its blurriness, but otherwise I regret nothing. This picture, by the way, is not a trick of perspective. Michelle is less than a foot away from these swords. They just really are that big.

Unbelievable, right? A little ridiculous, but mostly in a good way.

Kind of like Topkapı.

3 comments

  1. Ann Hoedeman · · Reply

    two things: 1) they need more sweaters in Fargo, and 2) did one of the big swords belong to Democles?

    Sent from my iPad

    >

    Like

  2. […] Check out the Harem of Topkapı Palace — This private area of long hallways, hundreds of rooms, and a smattering of courtyards was where the sultan’s mother, siblings, concubines (i.e., kidnapped girls presented to the sultan as gifts), and eunuchs (castrated men employed as harem guards) lived. And as long as we’ll be at the palace, it’s always enjoyable (we’ve been here before) to stroll the sumptuous grounds and gawk at the bling (Emeralds the size of kiwis! Everyday household items encrusted in gold and diamonds!). Update: Done.  […]

    Like

  3. […] Topkapi Palace: Just behind Hagia Sofia, you can check out the harem to see how Ottoman sultans and their women actually lived, admire an impressive weapons, see a bunch of religious relics of questionable legitimacy, and gawk at loads of bling (Emeralds the size of kiwis! Everyday household items encrusted in diamonds!). Basilica Cistern: Just beneath the heart of the Old City lies the largest of Istanbul’s several hundred ancient cisterns. The Byzantines built the underground water source using hundreds of columns, many of which were salvaged from temples, hence the occasional carved stone head lying around. […]

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: